POS 313 - Congress
FALL 2005
(Tuesdays 1:40-4:30 p.m.)
PS H153 -
Instructor: Dr. Michelle L. Chin E-mail:Michelle.chin@asu.edu
Office: 6774
TA:
COURSE OBJECTIVES
At a press conference in July 1937, President Franklin D.
Roosevelt famously declared that “It is the duty of the President to propose
and it is the privilege of the Congress to dispose.” Forty-one years later in a television
interview, President Jimmy Carter said that one of the “two unpleasant
surprises [about
REQUIRED TEXTS
Congress and its Members 10th edition
[Roger H. Davidson & Walter J. Oleszek (CQ: 2005)]
CQ’s Legislative Simulation [Julie
Dolan & Marni Ezra (CQ: 2001)]
The Dance of Legislation [Eric Redman (University of Washington: 1973,
2001)]
How Congress Works and Why You Should Care [Lee H.
Hamilton (
GRADE (Keep track of your grade using the worksheet on
pg. 8)
40% Simulation: There
are several important components to the simulation. You will receive credit for completing each
of these tasks as they are assigned. The
percentage for each task is listed below; these numbers should sum to 40. The grade for the simulation is determined as
follows: 20% for written work (reports, testimony, remarks, etc), and 20% for
your attendance and participation during the committee and floor
debate phases of the simulation (YOU WILL LOSE POINTS IF YOU ARE LATE
TO ANY OF THESE PROCEEDINGS). Business
attire required during ALL COMMITTEE & FLOOR DEBATE phases of the
simulation (FYI, see http://www.jobweb.
com/Research/mensattire‑1.htm or http://ecglink.com/newsletter/dress.shtml).
40% Exams: Four
closed-book exams worth 100 points each and consisting of all or some
multiple-choice & short answer questions will be given throughout the
semester. No make-up exams without a
university-approved excuse or prior approval of the instructor.
15% Analytical Essay: One analytical essay about the member of
Congress that you will role-play in the simulation. Analyze the member’s constituency, policy
& political agenda, and institutional activities. This 8-10 page, typed,
double-spaced essay is worth 100 points & MUST BE POSTED to the
Blackboard drop box by 11:59 p.m.
5% Analytical Book Review: One
5-page, typed double-spaced review of The Dance of Legislation or How
Congress Works and Why You Should Care is worth 100 points & MUST BE POSTED to the Blackboard drop box by 11:59 p.m.
BLACKBOARD I will post lecture notes and exam review
sheets on Blackboard. You MUST have an
active ASURITE id to access these materials.
Online discussion boards will be used for committee communication in the
legislative simulation.
Footnote 18 contracts To obtain footnote 18 Honors credit for POS
313, you must complete ALL of the required assignments listed above with a 90%
average or higher, and ALL of the following: (1) consult with me about the
topic of a 20-page, thoroughly researched, term paper that you will write, (2)
get a 90% or higher on the paper, and (3) pass a comprehensive, ALL-ESSAY final
exam with a 90% or higher.
ACADEMIC INTEGRITY: Thou shalt not cheat or steal another’s
words/work and pass it off as your own.
In this class, the penalty for violations of the university’s code of
conduct regarding academic integrity is a grade of XE (failure due to academic
dishonesty) for the class. WARNING TO SENIORS: the
university also reserves the right to revoke your degree for academic
dishonesty. For details, see http://www.asu.edu/studentlife/judicial/integrity.html.
Online Resources (not a complete listing)
U.S. House of Representatives [www.house.gov],
U.S. Senate [www.senate.gov]
Bills & legislation [http://thomas.loc.gov],
Scholarly journal articles [www.jstor.org]
Media: C-SPAN [www.cspan.org], Congressional Quarterly [www.cq.com], National Journal [www.nationaljournal.com],
Washington Post (www.washingtonpost.com), New York
Times (www.nytimes.com)
Campaign finance & voting records: Federal Election
Commission [www.fec.gov], Center for Responsive
Politics [www.crp.org], Project Vote Smart [www.vote-smart.org]
Think tanks: American Enterprise Institute [www.aei.org], Brookings Institute [www.brook.edu], Cato Institute [www.cato.org],
Campaign Finance Institute [www.cfinst.org], Urban
Institute [www.urban.org]
Analytical Book Reviews
Write a 5-page typed (double-spaced, 12 point font, 1 inch
margins), carefully argued, and clearly structured, analytical review of Eric
Redman’s The Dance of Legislation or Lee Hamilton’s How Congress
Works and Why You Should Care. You
may write an extra review for up to 5% extra credit.
REDMAN: In your
review, you should compare and contrast policymaking in the House and the
Senate using examples from Redman’s account and Congress and Its Members
as well as the simulation. What challenges
do members of the House and Senate face when working with “the other body” on
legislation? How does the “real world”
account compare to the picture of Congress that emerges from the textbook and
your experiences in the simulation?
A. Layout
Title Page: Your name; due date; name of the member you are
writing about.
Headers: Put your name as a header for each page of your
paper; AND number the pages.
BE CLEAR. Clearly organized papers get better grades:
Introduction‑
Tell the reader what to expect in the paper.
Body‑
Explain what you want the reader to understand.
Conclusion‑
Briefly review your arguments & link everything together one last time.
Use the American Political Science Association citation
style (see http://dept.lamar.edu/polisci/DRURY/drury.html).
B. Conceptual
Organization
Constituency: Members’
activities derive largely from their constituency's interests. Be sure to discuss the specific
characteristics of the member’s district and constituency. Using the Internet (see Federal Election
Commission, or Center for Responsive Politics), identify the main campaign
contributors from the member’s district.
Evaluate and discuss the connection, if any, between the member’s
activities on issues and the campaign contributors.
Electoral Vulnerability: Describe and discuss the member’s electoral
vulnerability. Is the member in a safe
or marginal district? Who or what are
the main obstacles or challenges to the member’s re-election in 2006? What has the member done (or what should the
member do) to anticipate these electoral threats? What constituencies are more/less supportive
of the member, and why do they take these positions for/against the member?
Committees and position in the party: Describe
and discuss the member’s committee assignments and activities that relate to
their party. Evaluate the connection between
constituency and committee assignments and participation.
Issues: From Congressional Quarterly
Weekly Report and Congressional Quarterly Almanac, identify the policy issues
that are important to the member.
Briefly describe, then assess their activities in Congress (see CQ
Almanac and other almanacs, also look for other news reports about the member’s
legislative activities).
Link the key points together: The important thing is to make links between
these sections. Your job is to analyze
the information about the member’s electoral vulnerability and constituency,
committee and party responsibilities, and policy goals to understand and
explain how they are connected.
C. Some Helpful Hints
*Write clearly and concisely.
*Avoid run-on sentences and lengthy, rambling, unfocused
paragraphs; and use the spell-checker.
*Be sure to elaborate your thoughts and ideas fully! I can’t
read your mind, only your paper.
*Remember Murphy’s Law (the computer will crash, the printer
won’t print, the car won’t start, the universe will conspire against you) if
you wait until the last minute to complete this assignment.
The Fine Print
Schedule of Assignments & Class Discussion topics
I. What is Congress? |
|||
Week
1. Aug.
23 |
Congressional
History & Change Congress and Its Members (
1. What are the 2 Congresses? 2. What kind of legislature did the Framers
construct? 3. Why is a legislature of this type necessary
in a representative democracy? 4. What lessons will you learn from
participating in the simulation? IN
CLASS: SELECT THE MEMBER OF CONGRESS
YOU WILL ROLE PLAY IN THE SIMULATION NOTE:
Photos of individual Members of Congress will be taken in class. |
||
II. Congressional Elections NOTE
– The first 15 minutes of each regular class day are reserved for “Morning
Business” during which time members may give one minute statements. |
|||
Week
2. Aug.
30 |
Congress and Its Members (
|
||
Week
3. Sept.
6 |
1:45-3:00
p.m. EXAM 1 – DUE: Signed Statement (p.9) is worth 5 points on the exam. 3:15-4:30 p.m. – WORKSHOP to discuss the essays due next week. |
||
III. Members of Congress |
|||
Week
4. Sept.
13 |
Congress and Its
Members ( ** Dance
of Legislation (Redman): pg. 1-97 DUE: Analytical essay on the Member of Congress
you are role-playing. Be sure to
discuss the characteristics of your district, your committee assignments,
policy agenda, and any leadership roles that you play in your political
party. In general: Assess your
electoral vulnerability and prospects for re-election in 2006. The essay should be 5-10 pages, typed,
double-spaced. Be sure to properly cite the material and include a list of
references. References MUST include
the CQ Politics in
1. What is the difference between Hill style
and Home style? 2. What does constituency mean? 3. What is representation? DOL: Why
does Redman write this book? What
brings him to DC? How are legislative
policies initiated? What kind of
preparation and research go into developing legislation, recruiting members
of Congress to support it, and moving the legislation on the policy
agenda? What does the phrase “dance of
legislation” refer to? |
||
IV. Working in Congress |
|||
Week
5. Sept.
20 |
Party
Leadership & Committees Congress and Its Members ( How Congress Works ( DUE: Draft 1 amendment to your committee’s bill & 1 amendment to the other committee’s bill; also include a brief “plain English” description for each amendment. You may offer additional amendments during mark-up & floor debate, but just turn in these 2 amendments for credit (worth 5% of 40% simulation grade). Use appropriate legal language to draft the amendment. DUE IN BLACKBOARD DROP BOX by 11:59 P.M.
1. What is the role of party leadership in
Congress? Why is it important? 2. What is the significance of the committee
system in Congress? 3. How do members get committee assignments? 4. Why would members wish to participate (and
how do they participate) in committees? |
||
Week
6. Sept.
27 |
1:45-3:00
p.m. EXAM 2 3:15-4:30
p.m. FILM/GUEST |
||
V. Congress & Policy Process |
|||
Week
7. Oct. 4 |
Procedures
& Scheduling Congress and Its Members ** Dance of Legislation (Redman):
pg. 98-162 DUE: 2-3 pg list of questions you will ask EACH of the interest group witnesses in your committee hearing in the simulation (worth 5 of the 40% simulation grade). DUE IN BLACKBOARD DROP BOX by 11:59 P.M.
1. What are the differences between the
legislative processes in the House and the Senate? 2. How do these differences affect the ability
of Congress to "get things done”? 3. What are the (dis)advantages to the
different rules concerning floor debate in the House & Senate? 4. If you could change the rules, what would
you change? DOL: What
are the real-world politics of committee & floor proceedings in the
Senate? How has the legislative
proposal changed from its inception? |
||
Week
8. Oct.
11 |
The President, Bureaucracy & the Courts
Congress and Its Members
|
||
Week
9. Oct.
18 |
1:45-3:00
p.m. EXAM 3 3:15-4:30
p.m. FILM/GUEST SPEAKER |
||
Week
10. Oct.
25 |
Interest
Groups Congress and Its
Members ** Dance of Legislation (Redman): pg.
163-232
1. Who are organized interest groups? 2. What’s the role of interest groups in the
congressional policy making process? 3. What’s the significance of access,
participation and influence of organized interests in the policy process? DOL: What
role did organized interests play in the process regarding S. 4106? What is your perception of Sen. Magnuson
given Redman’s description of the senator?
Based on your reading of this book, how important do you think staff
is in assisting and influencing the members of Congress they work for? |
||
Week
11. Nov 1. |
Budget,
Domestic & National Security Policy Congress and Its Members
How Congress Works ( ** Dance of Legislation (Redman): pg. 233-308
1. Why does Congress place such importance on
control of the budget? 2. What does it take to pass a budget? 3. What’s Congress’ role regarding national
security policy?
1. What were unexpected events relating to
passage of S. 4106? In hindsight, what
information would Redman have needed to correctly anticipate these events? 2. What constitutes the full measure of
success when it comes to passing a bill?
Would you say that Sen. Magnuson was successful with respect to S.
4106? 3. How has Congress changed since Redman first
wrote the book in 1973? In what ways
do you think the legislative outcome
of S. 4106 would be different if it was considered in the current Congress? |
||
Week
12. Nov. 8 |
Congress’
Role in a Representative Democracy Congress and Its Members ( Reading
Questions: 1. 2.What
institutional aspects of Congress pose challenges to the exercise of
representative democracy? 3.What
are the (dis)advantages of an informed public? What do you think of the proposed reforms?
Are they really necessary? Why or why
not? 4.How do
you think the election results affect Congress-White House relations? In what
ways do you expect the policy agenda in the 109th Congress to
differ from the 108th Congress? |
||
Week
13. Nov.
15 |
3:15-4:30
p.m. FINAL PREP FOR HEARING |
||
VI. If I Were A Representative...Business attire
required for remainder of semester. |
|||
Week
14. Nov.
22 *Business attire |
DUE:
Analytical Book Review DUE IN BLACKBOARD DROP BOX by
11:59 P.M.
NOTE:
Class location changes for this week only!! 1:50-3:05
p.m. Hearings
(Worth 5 of 40% of simulation grade) Energy & Commerce
meets in TBA Transportation &
Infrastructure meets in TBA 3:20-4:30
p.m. Mark up
(Worth 5 of 40% of simulation grade) Energy & Commerce meets in TBA Transportation &
Infrastructure meets in TBA |
||
Week
15. Nov.
29 *Business attire |
CLASS MEETS IN REGULAR CLASSROOM!SIMULATION
Phase 2: Floor Debate (Worth 5 of 40% of simulation grade) 1:45-2:15
p.m. Morning Business, House Floor.
2:25-3:25
p.m. Debate on Rule 3:30-4:30
p.m. General Debate on HR____ HR
1415 Patient Access to Responsible Care Act of 1997 HR
1595 Safe & Sober Streets Act |
||
Week
16. Dec. 6 *Business attire |
SIMULATION
Phase 2: Floor Debate Continued (Worth 5 of 40% of simulation grade) 1:45-2:45
p.m. General Debate on HR_____ 2:45-3:00
p.m. Roll Call votes on HR 1415, HR
1595 3:15-4:15
p.m. Debriefing
1. From the readings & participating in
the simulation, what have you learned about the congressional policymaking
process that helps explain public perceptions about Congress? 2. Does Congress fulfill its role to represent
the people, and to check the powers of the executive and judicial branches of
government? 3. How have your opinions about Congress
changed since the beginning of the semester? NOTE: Book reviews will be returned today. |
1. Sample - One Minute Statements from the
Congressional Record
OLD
GLORY CONDOMS ALLOWED TO UNFURL (House of Representatives - March 09, 1993
[Page: H1061]
(Mr.
TRAFICANT asked and was given permission to address the House for 1 minute.)
Mr.
TRAFICANT.
Madam Speaker, the Old Glory Condom Corp. appealed a prior decision that banned
their red, white, and blue condoms. Now, Old Glory contended that the use of
their red, white, and blue condoms was in fact a patriotic act. And, guess
what? The U.S. Trademark Office of Appeals agreed with that.
Here is what the panel said. The name Old
Glory and its logo of a flag shaped like and unfurled condom is neither
scandalous nor offensive nor unconstitutional.
No wonder the American people are losing confidence in our Government. What is next, the Congressional Medal for Benedict Arnold? When our Government starts treating the flag like an Old Glory condom , something should be done. [Page: H1062]
ASIAN
PACIFIC ISLANDER AMERICAN HERITAGE MONTH -- (House of Representatives - May 04,
2005) [Page: H2885] (Ms. SOLIS asked and
was given permission to address the House for 1 minute)
Ms.
SOLIS. Mr.
Speaker, today I rise in celebration of Asian Pacific Islander American
Heritage Month. As a member of the Congressional Asian Pacific Islander
American Caucus, I am proud to pay tribute to the 120,000 individuals of Asian
descent that I represent in the 32nd Congressional District in
2. Sample - FLOOR STATEMENT from the
Congressional Record
Mr.
HAYWORTH.
Mr. Speaker, it was my honor to represent the Gila River Indian community in
the Congress of the United States for my first 8 years of service in this
institution. And although redistricting in my home State has shifted the
boundaries of the Congressional District I now represent, I continue to enjoy a
very productive working relationship with and on behalf of the
Mr. Speaker, I would urge my colleagues to
support this very important legislation. My friend from
Mr. Speaker, this points out a challenge we
have faced time and again with the first Americans, because in too many instances,
our government has come up short in its stewardship of Native American monies.
The
Mr. Speaker, the dominant media culture in
this town, so fond of playing up differences that may exist among us, may
little note nor long remember what transpires with this legislation today. But
it is very profound, because it lifts a burden of uncertainty from members of
the
Mrs.
BONO. Mr.
Speaker, I rise in strong support of H.R. 810. I would like to thank the
chairman for all of his work in bringing this bill to the floor, and I would
like to thank my leadership for allowing a vote on this important
legislation. As Representatives, we are
in the unique position to frequently meet with a wide cross-section of people,
many of whom are suffering from debilitating diseases, injuries, and ailments.
These millions of patients, as well as their loved ones, have a clear message
for policymakers: we support this research and we need their help. Opponents of
this bill have argued that we should not use Federal funds to pay for embryonic
stem cell research. I respectfully disagree. The issue at hand is allowing for
more pristine stem cell lines to be eligible for research. Scientists and
researchers throughout the
Former First Lady Nancy Reagan has said
about embryonic stem cell research: ``Science has presented us with a hope
called stem cell research, which may provide our scientists with many answers
that for so long have been beyond our grasp. I just don't see how we can turn
our backs on this. We have lost so much time already. I just really can't bear
to lose any more.''
We all know that the impetus for Nancy
Reagan was the battle that her husband, President Ronald Reagan, fought with
Alzheimer's disease. The former first lady is not alone. Over 4.5 million
Americans are affected by Alzheimer's. I am encouraged by scientists' claims
that embryonic stem cells will allow for more research on Alzheimer's,
including the possibility that they may be used to grow new brain cells to
replace the brain tissue destroyed by the disease.
Dana
Reeves, the widow of actor and activist Christopher Reeves, sat with me less
than 2 months ago and shared her family's devastating story. The potential for
turning the hope for spinal cord injury into reality is evident, and I believe
that by passing this legislation we can clear the way for research to move
forward. Dana and Nancy are just two of the more visible faces of public
figures who have asked for this research.
Mr. Speaker, I implore my colleagues to please support this legislation,
H.R. 810.
|
|||
GRADE WORKSHEET |
DUE DATE |
Your grade |
% Final Grade |
Analytical Essay- 8-10 pg (no late
papers without univ-approved excuse) 100 pts. |
SEPT. 13 |
|
15% |
Simulation Papers (late papers NEED univ-approved
excuse) |
|
|
20% |
1 pg One Minute
remarks for House floor (morning business) + Oral Statement in Class |
Aug. 30-Nov. 29 (except Exam Days & Nov. 22) |
|
5% |
Committee
amendment |
SEPT. 20 |
|
5% |
2-3 pg list of
questions for witnesses @ committee hearing |
OCT. 4 |
|
5% |
Two floor
statements on EACH bill (1pg statement on HR 1415 + 1pg statement on HR 1595) |
OCT. 11 |
|
5% |
Participation in Simulation
(BUSINESS ATTIRE; points deducted if you’re late!) |
|
|
20% |
Hearing |
NOV. 22 |
|
5% |
Markup |
NOV. 22 |
|
5% |
Morning Business,
Debate on Rule, General Debate |
NOV. 29 |
|
5% |
General Debate |
DEC. 6 |
|
5% |
1 Analytical Book Review - 5-6 pg (no late
papers w/o univ-approved excuse) (Write an extra book review for up to 5% extra
credit) 100 points per review. |
NOV. 22 |
|
5% |
Dance of
Legislation |
|
|
|
How
Congress Works |
|
|
|
Exams – 1:45-3 p.m. (no make-ups w/o univ-approved
excuse) – 100 points each |
|
|
40% |
1 |
SEPT. 6 |
|
|
2 |
SEPT. 27 |
|
|
3 |
OCT. 18 |
|
|
4 |
NOV. 15 |
|
|
Final Grade |
|
100% |
|
Calculate your SEMESTER GRADE
A+
(98+) A
(94-97) A-
(90-93) B+
(88-89) B
(84-87) B-
(80-83) C+ (78-79)
C (74-77) C- (70-73) D+
(68-69) D
(64-67) D-
(60-63) E (59 or
lower) XE (failure due to
academic dishonesty) |
Final
Grade: |
Student’s
Name: |
Section
A. Paper Layout & Structure (10
points):
up to 2 points for each line, except as noted. |
|
Points |
Criteria |
|
Title
Page: Your name; due date; name of the member you are writing about. |
|
Headers:
Put your name as a header for each page of your paper; AND number the pages |
|
8-10
pages |
|
double‑spaced,
12 point font, 1 inch margins |
|
Work
properly cited List of references in APSA style. |
Subtotal
Section A |
Additional
comments: |
Section
B. Conceptual Organization (90 points) |
|
|
Constituency: Members’ activities derive largely from their
constituency's interests. Using data from the Federal Election Commission
(see also Center for Responsive Politics), identify the main campaign
contributors from the member’s district.
Discuss the connection, if any, between the member’s activities on
issues and the campaign contributors.
(15 points) |
|
Electoral Vulnerability: Describe
and discuss the member’s electoral vulnerability. Is the member in a safe or marginal
district? Who or what are the main
obstacles or challenges to the member’s re-election in 2006? What has the member done (or what should
the member do) to anticipate these electoral threats? What constituencies are more/less
supportive of the member, and why do they take these positions for/against
the member? (15 points) |
|
Committees and position in the party: Describe and discuss the
member’s committee assignments and activities that relate to their party. (15
points) |
|
Issues: From the member’s home page and mostly from Congressional
Quarterly Weekly Report and Congressional Quarterly Almanac, identify
the policy issues that are important to the member. (15 points) |
|
Describe
and discuss the member’s activities in Congress (see CQ Almanac and other
almanacs, also look for other news reports about the member’s legislative
activities). (15 points) |
|
Link the three key points together: The important thing is to make links
between these three sections. (15 points) |
Subtotal
Section B |
Additional
comments: |
Section
C. Deduct additional points for any of
the following “infractions”: |
|
|
Sloppy,
incoherent, unclear, rambling sentences/writing style. Poor
spelling and grammar |
|
Other
(please describe) |
Subtotal
Section C |
Additional
comments: |
Total
(A + B + C) |
#
Please read the following CAREFULLY, and sign your name in the line provided. Turn in this form on or BEFORE Exam 1 on SEPT. 6. This is worth 5 points on the exam.
My signature below confirms that I have read this syllabus
carefully and understand the due dates for all assignments and exams in POS
313, as well as any location changes for the legislative simulation on Nov. 22,
29 and Dec. 6. I acknowledge that the
heavy workload in September and October means that I will be finished with all
requirements for this class by Dec. 6.
Finally, I also agree to abide by the
________________________________________________
(Your name)
(Date)